The Trust Debt

When product managers over-promise to keep everyone happy, they take out a debt... in trust

The Temptation to Please

Every product manager has felt the pull.

The VP of Sales wants that customer-requested feature to land this quarter. Marketing needs a flashy launch to hit campaign timelines. The CEO casually drops, "It’d be great if we could ship this before the next raise."

And in the moment—on the call, in the meeting, at the offsite—you say yes.

You say yes because you want to be seen as capable. You say yes because pushing back takes emotional energy you don’t have that day. You say yes because you genuinely want to deliver.

And with each yes, your product plans bend. They stretch past the point of realism. Eventually, they snap.

The short-term result? Everyone feels good.

The long-term consequence? You’ve taken out a loan. Not in dollars. In trust.

---

What Is Trust Debt?

Trust debt is what accumulates when there’s a consistent gap between what you say will happen and what actually happens.

It’s like technical debt, but instead of trading off future engineering effort, you're trading off future belief in your word.

It shows up in quiet ways:

• Stakeholders stop reading your updates.

• Teams start padding your timelines because they assume you’re overly optimistic.

• Leadership smiles politely in your reviews but makes decisions based on backchannels.

Trust debt is subtle, corrosive, and hard to repay.

---

The Human Drivers Behind Over-Promising

It’s easy to say, “Just don’t commit to what you can’t deliver.”

But in the real world, over-promising is rarely about malice or incompetence. It’s usually human.

1. Fear of Conflict

Saying "no" or "not now" can feel like you're letting someone down. Many PMs, especially those earlier in their leadership journey, would rather avoid the discomfort.

2. Misplaced Optimism

We believe in our teams. We think if we push hard enough, we might be able to pull it off. Hope becomes a strategy.

3. Identity Tied to Delivery

When your worth feels tied to how much you ship, you say yes to prove yourself. Even when the odds are bad.

Recognizing these patterns isn’t weakness. It’s wisdom. The best PMs learn to lead through these feelings, not ignore them.

---

Signs You're Accumulating Trust Debt

Most PMs don’t realize they’re in trust debt until the damage is visible. Here are early indicators:

1. Repeated Misses Without Recalibration

If you’re missing goals, timelines, or outcomes consistently without adjusting expectations publicly, you’re likely in trouble.

2. Private Skepticism, Public Agreement

If people nod in meetings but express doubts in DMs or side conversations, trust is already fractured.

3. Passive Participation in Reviews

If stakeholders stop challenging your decisions—or stop showing up altogether—it might be a sign they’ve lost confidence.

---

How to Rebuild Trust

The good news? Trust debt can be repaid. But like any debt, it takes intention, consistency, and time.

1. Reset the Baseline

Get real with yourself and your stakeholders.

• Acknowledge misses.

• Share updated assumptions.

• Stop the bleeding before you try to heal.

Scenario: You’ve missed key product outcomes for a couple quarters. Rather than pushing forward as if nothing’s wrong, you hold a reset meeting. You present a revised strategy, acknowledge what went wrong, and involve the team in building a new path forward.

2. Shrink the Commitments, Increase the Cadence

Instead of large, high-stakes promises, commit to smaller increments and deliver them reliably.

Scenario: You shift from promising a major feature overhaul by the end of the quarter to releasing improvements iteratively every two weeks. This rebuilds momentum and gives stakeholders tangible progress to react to.

3. Narrate the Trade-Offs

Help others understand the why behind changes. People forgive delays more than they forgive silence.

Scenario: You explain to Sales that the requested feature is being delayed to address key usability issues raised in research. You offer alternatives and a timeline for follow-up.

4. Reinvest in Relationships

Trust doesn’t live in docs or decks—it lives in people.

• Schedule 1:1s.

• Ask for feedback.

• Be transparent about your own learning process.

---

Shifting the Culture

Organizations with low trust debt have cultures that value realism over performance theater. You can model that, even if others aren’t.

1. Celebrate Honesty, Not Just Optimism

When someone raises a risk early, acknowledge it publicly. Show that transparency is valued.

2. Normalize Saying “I Don’t Know”

It’s okay to share uncertainty. It builds credibility when you do know.

3. Push Back With Respect

A well-framed "no" builds more trust than a fragile "yes."

Example Script:

“I understand the importance of this ask. Given our current capacity and critical priorities, we’d be risking other outcomes to commit to this now. I’d prefer we aim for later in the year and revisit mid-next month if bandwidth opens up."

---

Leading With Integrity

The best PMs are not the ones who make the boldest promises. They’re the ones whose teams and stakeholders know they mean what they say.

They build a reputation not for heroics, but for integrity.

They don’t trade trust for short-term applause.

Because they know that product work is not just a series of tasks—it’s a series of promises.

And trust is the most valuable currency we have.

---

Thanks for reading.

If this resonated with you, I’d love to hear:

• Have you ever been in trust debt?

• What helped you recover?

• What do you wish you’d done differently?